The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor and the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor are both well-regarded options for professional and home studio use, yet they have distinct differences that cater to varied audio monitoring needs. The HS4 is a smaller option, designed for environments where space is a constraint but quality should not be compromised. Its compact design makes it ideal for small studios or home setups where a precise sound is required without overwhelming the space. The HS5, on the other hand, is slightly larger and offers a more robust sound, making it suitable for larger studio environments where a more comprehensive audio range is needed.
Sound quality is a crucial factor in any monitor, and both models deliver excellent performance, though with some distinctions. The HS4 offers a clean and accurate sound with a focus on midrange frequencies, which is beneficial for mixing and mastering tasks that require clarity and precision. Meanwhile, the HS5 provides a broader frequency range, extending from low to high frequencies, which offers a more detailed sound profile. This makes the HS5 better suited for those who require a more detailed soundscape for intricate audio work.
In terms of power and amplification, the HS5 stands out with its built-in bi-amplified design, which provides separate amplifiers for its woofer and tweeter. This results in a more powerful and balanced sound output that can fill larger rooms effectively. On the other hand, the HS4, while still delivering clear and precise sound, may not match the HS5's power level, making it more appropriate for smaller spaces or for users who do not require a high output volume.
Considering their design and connectivity, both monitors feature a sleek and professional look typical of Yamaha's HS series, with a distinctive white cone woofer and a high-performance tweeter. They both offer flexible connectivity options, including XLR and TRS inputs, which allow for easy integration into various audio setups. However, the HS5's slightly larger size may offer more versatility in terms of placement options, as it can handle a broader frequency response effectively.
In conclusion, choosing between the Yamaha HS4 and HS5 depends on your specific needs and studio environment. For smaller setups and those prioritizing midrange clarity, the HS4 is an excellent choice. For larger spaces or those requiring a broader and more powerful sound, the HS5 proves to be a more suitable option. Both models uphold Yamaha's reputation for quality and precision in audio monitoring, ensuring reliable performance for professionals and enthusiasts alike.
In this comprehensive article, we will delve into a detailed comparison of the Yamaha HS4 and HS5 studio monitors. We will examine their specifications, highlighting both their strengths and weaknesses, to provide you with all the information needed to choose the right studio monitor for your needs.
User Rating Based on Analysis of Reviews | |
---|---|
|
Show More |
Pros: | |
---|---|
|
|
Cons: | |
---|---|
|
|
Key Specs | |
---|---|
Monitor Type & Configuration | |
Active 2-Way | Active 2-Way |
Total Power Output | |
70 W | 26 W per Monitor |
Tweeter | |
1x 1" / 25.4 mm Dome | 1x 1" / 25.4 mm Dome |
Woofer | |
1x 5" / 12.7 cm Cone |
1x 4.5" / 11.4 cm Cone |
Frequency Range | |
74 Hz to 24 kHz (-3 dB) 54 Hz to 30 kHz (-10 dB) |
83 Hz to 20 kHz (-3 dB) 60 Hz to 22 kHz (-10 dB) |
Audio I/O | |
1x XLR 3-Pin Balanced Input (10 Kilohms) 1x 1/4" TRS Balanced Input (10 Kilohms) |
2x Combo XLR-1/4" TRS Balanced Mic/Line Input (20 Kilohms) 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Unbalanced Line Input (10 Kilohms) 1x Stereo 2RCA Unbalanced Line Input (10 Kilohms) 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Speaker Input 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Headphone Output 1x Binding Post Pair Speaker Output |
When comparing the Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor and the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor, both models are categorized as active 2-way monitors, providing a solid foundation for studio monitoring. However, the HS4 is equipped with a total power output of 26 W per monitor, while the HS5 significantly boosts this to 70 W, allowing for greater volume and headroom in the HS5.Show More
In terms of driver configuration, both monitors feature a 1" / 25.4 mm dome tweeter, but the HS4 has a 4.5" / 11.4 cm cone woofer, whereas the HS5 steps up the bass performance with a 5" / 12.7 cm cone woofer. This difference in woofer size contributes to the HS5's extended frequency range, with the HS4 reaching 83 Hz to 20 kHz (-3 dB) and the HS5 offering a broader range of 74 Hz to 24 kHz (-3 dB).
Additionally, the HS4 provides a more versatile set of audio inputs, including 2x combo XLR-1/4" TRS balanced mic/line inputs and various unbalanced line inputs, allowing for greater connectivity options. In contrast, the HS5 simplifies its input options with a XLR 3-Pin balanced input and a 1/4" TRS balanced input. This makes the HS4 a more flexible choice for setups requiring multiple input sources.
Overall, while both the Yamaha HS4 and HS5 monitors excel in delivering accurate sound reproduction, the HS5's increased power, larger woofer, and extended frequency response position it as a more capable option for those requiring higher performance in studio environments. However, the HS4’s varied input options may appeal to users looking for a more adaptable monitor solution.
General | |
---|---|
Number of Included Monitors | |
Single Monitor | Stereo Pair |
Enclosure | |
Bass-Reflex/Ported | Bass-Reflex/Ported |
Total Power Output | |
70 W | 26 W per Monitor |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor is designed as a Stereo Pair, making it ideal for users who require a balanced sound output across two speakers. In contrast, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor is offered as a Single Monitor, which can be suitable for those who prefer to start with one unit or need a dedicated monitor for specific applications.Show More
Both monitors share a Bass-Reflex/Ported enclosure design, which enhances low-frequency response and overall sound quality. However, their power output significantly differs, with the HS4 providing a total power output of 26 W per Monitor, while the HS5 delivers a more robust 70 W. This difference in power output can impact the volume levels and dynamic range, making the HS5 potentially better for larger spaces or more demanding audio applications.
Performance | |
---|---|
Frequency Range | |
74 Hz to 24 kHz (-3 dB) 54 Hz to 30 kHz (-10 dB) |
83 Hz to 20 kHz (-3 dB) 60 Hz to 22 kHz (-10 dB) |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor delivers a frequency range of 83 Hz to 20 kHz (-3 dB) and 60 Hz to 22 kHz (-10 dB). In contrast, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor offers a slightly broader frequency range, with 74 Hz to 24 kHz (-3 dB) and 54 Hz to 30 kHz (-10 dB). This makes the HS5 a better option for those seeking enhanced low-end performance and higher frequency response, making it suitable for a wider range of audio applications.Show More
When it comes to maximum sound pressure level (SPL), the HS4 boasts a maximum SPL of 102 dB (Peak), indicating its capability to deliver loud and clear sound without distortion. The HS5, while not explicitly listed, is generally regarded to perform similarly in terms of SPL but offers better overall output due to its superior frequency range. This makes the HS5 potentially more effective for both mixing and monitoring tasks in various studio environments.
Input handling differs slightly between the two monitors. The HS4 has a maximum input level of +20 dBu (Balanced) and +6 dBu (Unbalanced), allowing it to accommodate a variety of audio sources. Meanwhile, the HS5 features an analog input sensitivity/gain of -10 dBu, which indicates its design for compatibility with a range of devices but may suggest a different handling capability compared to the HS4. This factor may influence the choice depending on the user's specific audio setup requirements.
Signal Processing | |
---|---|
EQ | |
1x LF Shelf: -4 to 0 dB at 500 Hz (2 dB Increments) 1x HF Shelf: -2 to +2 dB at 2 kHz (2 dB Increments) |
1x LF Shelf: 0 to +4 dB at 500 Hz (2 dB Increments) 1x HF Shelf: 2 to -2 dB at 2 kHz (2 dB Increments) |
Filters | |
Parametric EQ | |
Crossover Frequency | |
2 kHz | 2.3 kHz |
Phase Adjustment | |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor and the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor both offer a range of features suitable for studio mixing and monitoring, but they differ in certain specifications that may influence a user's choice. The HS4 is equipped with an EQ that includes a LF Shelf ranging from 0 to +4 dB at 500 Hz and a HF Shelf from 2 to -2 dB at 2 kHz, allowing for a bit of customization in low and high frequencies. Its crossover frequency is set at 2.3 kHz, which is slightly higher compared to the HS5.Show More
On the other hand, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor presents a different EQ setup, featuring a LF Shelf that ranges from -4 to 0 dB at 500 Hz and a HF Shelf from -2 to +2 dB at 2 kHz. This configuration provides users with a wider range of attenuation in the low frequencies, which can be beneficial in achieving a more balanced sound in various environments. Additionally, the crossover frequency is lower at 2 kHz compared to the HS4, allowing for different sound dispersion characteristics.
While both monitors lack advanced features like filters, parametric EQ, and phase adjustment, their EQ settings and crossover frequencies set them apart. The HS4’s slightly higher crossover frequency and broader LF boost options may appeal to those looking for a brighter sound, while the HS5’s greater LF attenuation range and lower crossover frequency might benefit users who prefer a more controlled low-end response. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on the specific audio monitoring needs of the user.
Connectivity | |
---|---|
Audio I/O | |
1x XLR 3-Pin Balanced Input (10 Kilohms) 1x 1/4" TRS Balanced Input (10 Kilohms) |
2x Combo XLR-1/4" TRS Balanced Mic/Line Input (20 Kilohms) 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Unbalanced Line Input (10 Kilohms) 1x Stereo 2RCA Unbalanced Line Input (10 Kilohms) 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Speaker Input 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Headphone Output 1x Binding Post Pair Speaker Output |
Network I/O | |
USB | |
Wireless | |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor offers a versatile range of audio inputs, including 2x Combo XLR-1/4" TRS Balanced Mic/Line Inputs, which are suitable for various recording scenarios. Additionally, it features an 1x 1/8" / 3.5 mm TRS Unbalanced Line Input and an 1x Stereo 2RCA Unbalanced Line Input, providing flexibility for connecting different audio sources. Other noteworthy features include a 1/8" TRS Speaker Input and a 1/8" TRS Headphone Output, which enhance convenience for monitoring purposes. The HS4 also includes a Binding Post Pair Speaker Output for connecting to external speakers.Show More
In comparison, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor has a more streamlined audio input configuration with 1x XLR 3-Pin Balanced Input and 1x 1/4" TRS Balanced Input. While it supports balanced connections, it lacks the additional unbalanced inputs found in the HS4. Neither model includes Digital Audio I/O, Network I/O, USB, or Wireless capabilities, and neither is compatible with mobile apps, making them strictly analog monitors.
Overall, the HS4 provides a broader range of connectivity options, making it ideal for users needing multiple input sources. In contrast, the HS5's simpler input setup may appeal to those focused on balanced connections for more straightforward monitoring tasks. Each monitor serves its purpose effectively, catering to different user needs in the studio environment.
Power | |
---|---|
AC Input Power | |
Not Specified by Manufacturer | 100 to 240 VAC, 50/60 Hz |
Power Consumption | |
45 W | 15 W |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor operates with an AC Input Power range of 100 to 240 VAC at a frequency of 50/60 Hz, making it versatile for use in various electrical environments. Its Power Consumption is rated at 15 W, which contributes to its energy efficiency while delivering professional-grade sound quality.Show More
In contrast, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor does not specify its AC Input Power, which may limit some users seeking detailed electrical requirements. However, it has a higher Power Consumption of 45 W, indicating that it may offer a more powerful output and potentially enhanced audio performance compared to the HS4.
When it comes to physical specifications, the Yamaha HS5 is designed with a slightly larger footprint. It measures 6.7 x 11.2 x 8.7 inches (17 x 28.5 x 22.2 cm) and weighs 11.7 lb (5.3 kg), which may make it a more substantial presence in a studio setup. Both models utilize MDF for their enclosure material, ensuring durability and sound quality, yet the HS4 does not provide specific dimensions or weight, making direct size comparisons challenging.
In summary, the Yamaha HS4 offers a more energy-efficient option with its lower power consumption, while the HS5 boasts a potentially more robust performance with its higher power requirements. The choice between these two monitors will largely depend on the user's specific needs regarding power output, size, and studio requirements.
Packaging Info | |
---|---|
Package Weight | |
16.2 lb | 18.655 lb |
Box Dimensions (LxWxH) | |
16.4 x 12 x 10.2" | 13 x 12.9 x 11.7" |
The Yamaha HS4 Studio Monitor has a package weight of 18.655 lb, making it slightly heavier than its counterpart. This extra weight could be attributed to the build quality and materials used in its construction, which may contribute to its acoustic properties. The dimensions of the box for the HS4 are 13 x 12.9 x 11.7 inches, allowing for a compact footprint that can fit well in various studio environments.Show More
On the other hand, the Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor is lighter, with a package weight of 16.2 lb. This reduction in weight might make it more convenient for transport or rearranging in a studio setting. The box dimensions for the HS5 are 16.4 x 12 x 10.2 inches, which is slightly larger in length compared to the HS4, providing a different spatial profile that may affect placement options in your workspace.
In summary, while the Yamaha HS4 is heavier and more compact, the HS5 offers a lighter design with slightly larger dimensions. These differences could influence user preference based on individual studio needs and preferences in terms of weight and size considerations.
Customer Images | |
---|---|
|
Videos | |
---|---|
|
|